All Houses Apartments Filters Save Search

Homes For Rent in Middle Island, NY

1-3 of 3 rentals in Middle Island

SortSort by: Relevance

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath450 ft²

117 Flicker Dr

Middle Island, NY 11953

Beautiful One Bedroom Basement Apartment For Rent. Beautiful one bedroom basement apartment for rent in Middle Island, NY. New floors, new kitchen, new appliances and recessed lighting through-out. Off-street Parking. Right of Rt-25 Walking distance to shopping, bus stop, lake and much more. Max occupancy 2 people. No Pets and ...

Condo2 Beds1 Bath999 ft²

325 Tudor Lane #E32

Middle Island, NY 11953

We are now offering an ideal 2 bedroom 1 bathroom unit conveniently located in Middle Island NY 11953. Priced to go quick at $2760/month and decked out with the best assortment of features. Relax in a charming way of life that you will love. Contact us to get more details.

Condo2 Beds2 Baths750 ft²

248 Lake Pointe Circle #D12

Middle Island, NY 11953

Priced to go quick at just $2815 per mo, relax in a convenient way of life that you've been searching for. Impressive 2Bd 2Ba property now available in Middle Island 11953. Offered with an ideal array of property amenities.

Market information for Middle Island

As of April 2024 the median rental rate in Middle Island is $2,775 which is $83 (3%) less than the median of $2,858 for Suffolk County, $828 (43%) more than the median of $1,947 for New York and $1,178 (74%) more than the median of $1,597 for the United States.

	Median	1 Bed	2 Beds	3 Beds
Middle Island	$2,775	$2,371	$2,737	$3,218
Suffolk County	$2,858	$2,348	$2,855	$3,372
New York	$1,947	$1,541	$1,938	$2,360
United States	$1,597	$1,236	$1,565	$1,989

Nearby Cities

Port Jefferson Station

Nearby Zip Codes

Nearby Counties

Fairfield County

Property Types

Middle Island houses

Middle Island apartments

Middle Island rentals

Back to top

Are you a rental professional?

List your Middle Island available rental properties on RentalSource, Realtor, Zillow, Trulia, Hotpads and more. It's free, quick & easy.