Welcome to 2509A N Buffum St (Upper Unit) - a bright and spacious 3-bedroom, 1-bath back cottage located in Milwaukee's convenient 53212 area. This unit offers a comfortable layout with plenty of room for families, roommates, or anyone needing extra space.
Unit Features: Large living room with great natural light. Eat-in kitchen with ample cabinet and counter space. Three comfortably sized bedrooms with closet storage. Clean and functional full bathroom. Private entrance for added privacy. Street parking available.
Location Highlights: Close to downtown Milwaukee, shopping, and dining. Near parks, schools, and local conveniences. Easy access to public transportation and major roads.
Additional costs may included the following: Water Bill: $65/month. Resident Liability Insurance: $14.95 (Can be waived with Proof of insurance).
Move-in ready - schedule your showing today. Please be advised that a non-refundable $100 leasing fee is required to be paid within 48 hours of your application approval. In addition, the security deposit must also be paid within the same 48-hour period. Both payments are necessary to reserve the property under the applicant's name.
Failure to submit these payments within the specified timeframe may result in the property being made available to other applicants.
Pet Details: A maximum of two (2) pets is allowed (cats or dogs only). Small and medium breeds only. A one-time, non-refundable pet initiation fee of $100 is required and will be included in the move-in costs, payable upon move-in.
Monthly pet fees range from $20-$60, depending on the pet screening score.... Pet screening must be completed with the application or prior to move-in.
Having more pets than allowed is considered a lease violation and may result in lease termination.
Residents are responsible for maintaining cleanliness and proper care of the property. Please ensure pet waste is promptly cleaned up at all times.
14 days on RentalSource
RentalSource last checked: 22 hours ago · Listing updated: November 3, 2026
This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom house at 2509A N Buffum St in Milwaukee, WI 53212 rents for $1,600 a month. It has 1,300 square feet and is pet friendly. 2509A N Buffum St was advertised by PMI Property Pros on November 3, 2026.
How the Rent Compares
At $1,600 a month, this house is close to the typical rent for 3-bedroom houses and townhouses in Milwaukee (about $1,680).
Typical $1,680This home $1,600
$1,380$2,360
From 48 three-bedroom houses and townhouses listed in Milwaukee on RentalSource in November 2026: the scale holds eight in ten of them, and the shaded band the middle half.
$1,680Typical rent for 3-bedroom houses and townhouses in Milwaukee
This home was last listed for rent on RentalSource from April to August 2026, ending at $1,375. Today's rent is $225 higher.
Rent history for this home, newest first
Date
Event
Rent
Change
November 3, 2026
Listed for rent
$1,600+16.4%
+16.4%
August 2, 2026
Listing removed
$1,375
These are listed prices. What renters actually paid may have been different.
Affordability Calculator
Can I afford to live at 2509A N Buffum St?
Bedrooms
3 bedrooms
30%
10%Recommended50%
Move the slider to select the percentage of your monthly income you're comfortable spending on rent. Typically, it's advised to spend about 30% or less on housing.
Recommended income
$64,000 /year
With your chosen rent-to-income ratio, an annual income of $64,000 is recommended to comfortably afford this 3-bedroom rental priced at $1,600 per month.
How long would the trip to work or school be from here? Add where you go, and see the drive, bike ride or walk from this home and from every home you look at.
Drive times are for average traffic, so rush hour can take longer.