Find Rentals in Bay Shore

Houses for Rent

Apartments for Rent

Explore Listings

Property Managers

Listings Quality Policy

Renter Resources

Avoid Scams & Fraud

Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Rent Affordability Calculator

Help & Support

1 / 9

Updated - yesterday

Verified

Pet Friendly

Mid Island

35 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 - Suffolk County

Apartment

1-2 beds

1-1.5 baths

400-915 sqft

About 35 Penataquit Ave

Our quality studio, one and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments. Pet Friendly, Hardwood Floors, Washer, Dryer, Dishwasher, Air Conditioning, On-Site Manager, On-Site Maintenance & Surface Parking.

RentalSource last checked: June 12, 2026 · 3:26 PM ET

Managed by: Mid Island Apartments · (631) 665-6565 · iLoveLeasing

Listing data quality - We review listings daily to detect outdated, duplicate, or misleading information.

Property Summary

Property Type:	Apartment
Rental Fee:	$2,120 - $3,120
Bedrooms:	1-2 beds
Bathrooms:	1-1.5 baths

Size:	400-915 sqft
Pet Friendly:	Yes
Listing Status:	Active
ID:	83497283

Property Amenities

• Air Conditioning

• Dishwasher

• Hardwood Floors

• Pet Friendly

• Washer/Dryer Hk-up

Community Features

• Courtyard

• Parking

Unit Rates

Name	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Rent
732D	1	1	400	$2,120
531D	1	1	400	$2,155
652C	1	1	400	$2,205
151A	1	1	665	$2,250
91A	1	1	665	$2,545

Leasing Information

Application Fee (per Applicant): $20. Clean Sweep Fee: $400. Community Transfer Fee: $1,000. Late Fee: $50. Lock Change Fee: $200. Lock Out Fee: $100. Renter's Insurance: $15. Replacement - Access Device: $50. Replacement - Mailbox Key: $50. Returned Payment Fee: $75. Utility - Billing Administrative Fee: $5. Utility - Setup Fee: $10. Violation - Lease: $75. Violation - Trash: $100. Security Deposit: $2,155. Small Dogs Allowed & Cats Allowed. Pet Limit: 2. Pet Fee: $250. Pet Rent: $50. Pet Weight Limit: 40. Photos are an example of similar units within the building, actual unit may vary....

Additional Details

Apartments for rent in Bay Shore for $2,120-$3,120 with 1-2 beds, 1-1.5 baths, 400-915 sqft, pet friendly and located within Mid Island at 35 Penataquit Ave in Bay Shore, NY 11706. The averaged rental price of $2,620 is 1.5% ($39) lower than the average rent of $2,659 for apartments in Bay Shore, NY and 20.6% ($679) lower than the average rent of $3,299 for apartments in Suffolk County. Mid Island was advertised by Mid Island Apartments on April 24, 2026 at 9:35 AM ET and last updated yesterday at 3:26 PM ET.

Affordability Calculator

Can I afford to live at 35 Penataquit Ave?

Bedrooms

1 bedroom

Rent-to-income ratio

30%

10% Recommended 50%

Move the slider to select the percentage of your monthly income you're comfortable spending on rent. Typically, it's advised to spend about 30% or less on housing.

Recommended income

$84,800 /year

With your chosen rent-to-income ratio, an annual income of $84,800 is recommended to comfortably afford this 1-bedroom rental priced at $2,120 per month.

For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator or rent vs. buy calculator.

Apartment for rent

$2,120 - $3,120

Rent Affordability Calculator

Interested in 35 Penataquit Ave?

Find out more about this property & see if it's available now.

Property managed by:

Mid Island Apartments
(631) 665-6565

Avoid rental scams - Situations involving wire transfers or a landlord who can't meet you in person can be red flags.