Average Rent in Peyton, CO

Rentals in Peyton average about $2,404 a month as of October 2026. That is 24.2% higher than the Colorado average and 15.5% higher than the U.S. average.

Browse 22 rentals in Peyton

Rents as of October 2026 · Based on rentals advertised on RentalSource

$2,404

Average rent, Oct 2026

$1,997

Average 2-bedroom rent

+24.2%

Against Colorado ($1,936)

+15.5%

Against the U.S. ($2,082)

Average Rent in Peyton by Bedroom

Asking rents as of October 2026, beside Colorado and the country.

Size	Peyton	Colorado	U.S.	Income to afford it^*
All sizes	$2,404	$1,936	$2,082	$96,200
1 bedroom	$1,627	$1,475	$1,761	$65,100
2 bedrooms	$1,997	$1,907	$2,066	$79,900
3 bedrooms	$2,351	$2,541	$2,392	$94,000

^*Yearly household income at which this rent is 30% of income, before taxes. Studios are counted with 1-bedroom homes. Figures are asking rents advertised on RentalSource, not what tenants ended up paying.

For Rent in Peyton Now

Medians of the 23 listings advertised today, each counted once at the middle of its rents.

Browse rentals in Peyton

By monthly rent

Half of rentals ask between $2,473 and $2,825.

Under $2,50030% 7
$2,500 – $2,99952% 12
$3,000 – $3,49917% 4
$3,500 – $3,9990% 0
$4,000 – $4,4990% 0
$4,500 or more0% 0

By size

Rent, floor area and rent per square foot.

Size	Rent	Sq ft	Per sq ft	Listings
4+ bedrooms	$2,600	2,972	$0.88	17

By property type

Rent for each kind of home.

Type	Rent	Listings
Houses	$2,598	22

Peyton and Nearby Cities

Average rent as of October 2026 in the nearest cities we measure.

All Colorado cities

Peyton$2,404
Monument$2,381
Fountain$1,942
Colorado Springs$1,762
Manitou Springs$1,592

Average Rent Elsewhere in Colorado

All of Colorado