Average Rent in New Castle, IN

Rentals in New Castle average about $945 a month as of November 2026. That is 34.9% lower than the Indiana average and 53.6% lower than the U.S. average.

Rents as of November 2026 · Based on rentals advertised on RentalSource

$945
Average rent, Nov 2026
$1,036
Average 2-bedroom rent
-34.9%
Against Indiana ($1,452)
-53.6%
Against the U.S. ($2,036)

For Rent in New Castle Now

Medians of the 16 listings advertised today, each counted once at the middle of its rents.

Browse rentals in New Castle

New Castle and Nearby Cities

Average rent as of November 2026 in the nearest cities we measure.

All Indiana cities
Homes for Rent

Looking for a Rental in New Castle?

Half of the rentals available today ask between $619 and $874 a month. See them and message the property manager directly.