Filters Save search

Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Showing 3 rentals in Bay Shore, then 1 more within 25 miles, nearest first.
1-4 of 4 rentals

More rentals near Bay Shore

Viewing 1-4 of 4 rentals in and near Bay Shore
What to Know About

Life in Bay Shore & Beyond

Bay Shore shares many of the great qualities that make New York a desirable place to live.

New York state is known for its iconic skyscrapers, cultural diversity, and history. Visit notable museums, such as the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the American Museum of Natural History, and the Museum of Modern Art, to learn about the state's cultural heritage. New York is also home to prestigious universities like Columbia University, Cornell University, and New York University. The theater and art scene also thrive in New York, with world-renowned museums and performance centers in NYC like the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Lincoln Center, and Carnegie Hall.

From the breathtaking peaks of the Adirondack and Catskill Mountains to the scenic beauty of the Finger Lakes, outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty to explore. In terms of sports, New York is home to many professional teams like the New York Giants (NFL), Buffalo Bills (NFL), New York Rangers (NHL), New York Yankees (MLB), New York Mets (MLB), the New York Knicks (NBA), and Brooklyn Nets (NBA). In addition, embrace famous attractions like the Empire State Building, Statue of Liberty, Central Park, and Niagara Falls.

New York offers a high quality of life, a strong economy, and a rich cultural heritage, making it a great place to live.

Rental Market Trends

Bay Shore, NY

View full report

As of November 2026, Bay Shore's rental market is competitive, with rentals spending about 23 days on the market, faster than in New York (28), and rents up 3.7% over the past year. Bay Shore's average rent is 8.8% ($263) lower than the New York average of $2,977 and 33.3% ($678) higher than the U.S. average of $2,036.

Average Rent
$2,714
Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change
Increased0.23% ($6)
Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
Increased3.7% ($97)
Days on Market
23
Unit Type Average Rent Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
1 Bed $2,492 Increased0.99% ($24) Increased4.2% ($100)
2 Beds $2,935 Increased0.46% ($13) Increased3.9% ($111)
3 Beds $3,464 Increased0.53% ($18) Increased3.6% ($121)
Nearby Cities Average Rent Avg. Rent vs. Bay ShoreAverage Rent vs. Bay Shore Days on Market
West Islip $3,121 Increased15.0% ($407) 24 days
Deer Park $3,126 Increased15.2% ($412) 24 days
Central Islip $2,722 Increased0.3% ($8) 24 days
West Babylon $3,180 Increased17.2% ($466) 23 days
East Islip $3,209 Increased18.2% ($495) 24 days
Based on rentals advertised on RentalSource in and around Bay Shore.
Frequently Asked Questions
Bay Shore Rental Market FAQs

Explore rental prices, market conditions, and affordability in Bay Shore, NY.

The average rent in Bay Shore, NY is about $2,714 per month.
In Bay Shore, the average rent is about $2,492 per month for a 1-bedroom apartment, about $2,935 for a 2-bedroom apartment and about $3,464 for a 3-bedroom apartment.
The average rent in Bay Shore is 33.3% ($678) higher than the national average of $2,036 per month.
The rental market in Bay Shore, NY is currently competitive, with rentals spending about 23 days on the market, faster than in New York (28), and rents up 3.7% over the past year.
Based on the current averages, a household would need an annual income of about $117,400 to comfortably afford a 2-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore.
What's New on the Blog

Explore recent posts on our blog, curated for renters, landlords, and industry pros.

List Your Property for Rent

Are You a Rental Professional?

Advertise on RentalSource, Zillow, Realtor.com, Zumper and more to attract quality tenants faster and take your listings to the next level.