Find Rentals in Lake Mills

Homes for Rent Houses for Rent Apartments for Rent See Newest Listings

Explore Listings

Browse Rentals Browse Houses Browse Apartments

Market Trends

Rental Market Trends Hottest Rental Markets

Property Managers

List Your Rentals Property Manager Directory Listings Quality Policy

Renter Resources

Rent Calculator Rent vs. Buy Calculator Moving Center Search with AI Avoid Rental Scams

Help & Support

Blog FAQs About Us Contact Us

Save homes you like and get email alerts for new listings.

Filters Save search Homes for you

Homes & Apartments for Rent in Lake Mills, WI 53551

Showing 8 rentals in 53551, then 12 more within 25 miles, nearest first.

1-20 of 20 rentals

Apartment for rent at Rock Creek, 1000-1017 E Brewster Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/10

Managed by Northern Management

$1,899

Apartment2 Beds2 Baths1,173 ft²

Rock Creek

1000-1017 E Brewster Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

Amenities: Range & Direct Entry.

Apartment for rent at Rock Creek, 1011, 1014 & 1015 E Brewster Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/11

Featured

Managed by Northern Management

$1,799 - $1,899

Apartment2 Beds2 Baths1,104-1,232 ft²

Rock Creek

1011, 1014 & 1015 E Brewster Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

Experience tranquil, maintenance-free living at the newly constructed Rock Creek Apartments. Our thoughtfully designed property features ample green space and modern amenities with easy access to Hwy. 94. Rock Creek is located near Daybreak Foods and Faville Park, and just minutes from schools, health care, and outdoor recreation. For your convenience, we offer a variety of spacious apartment layouts. Lower apartments feature a beautiful private patio area, and upper units have large cathedral ceilings and private balconies. To enhance your living experience, all units feature quartz counter tops.

Apartment for rent at Tamarack Trails Estates, 215 Tamarack Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/10

Managed by Tamarack Trails Estates

$1,300

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath

Tamarack Trails Estates

215 Tamarack Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

This well-maintained 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment in Lake Mills, WI offers heat included for simpler monthly budgeting and the convenience of an in-unit washer and dryer. The unit features a private entry and includes a detached one-car garage. Located in town, the apartment provides easy access to local shops and services while delivering low-maintenance living with essential amenities.

Apartment for rent at Browns Court, 400 Browns Court, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/10

Managed by Northern Management

$1,099

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath634 ft²

Browns Court

400 Browns Court, Lake Mills, WI 53551

Enjoy the peaceful neighborhood of Lake Mills in our Browns Court apartments. Each apartment offers a spacious layout with large windows that have been newly updated, a storage locker along with off-street parking. A professional and caring staff plus emergency maintenance is available to residents, ensuring that you always have time to experience the comfort and beauty of your Browns Court home. Amenities: Range.

Apartment for rent at Rock Creek, 800-820 Brewster Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/10

Managed by Northern Management

$1,549 - $1,829

Apartment1-2 Beds1-2 Baths830-1,250 ft²

Rock Creek

800-820 Brewster Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

Amenities: Range. Apartments for rent in Lake Mills for $1,549-$1,829 with 1-2 beds, 1-2 baths, 830-1,250 sqft and located within Rock Creek at 800-820 Brewster Dr in Lake Mills, WI 53551.

Apartment for rent at Tamarack Trails Estates, 225 Tamarack Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/10

Managed by Tamarack Trails Estates

$1,250

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath

Tamarack Trails Estates

225 Tamarack Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

Discover a comfortable 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment in Lake Mills, WI. This upper unit features an in-unit washer and dryer for convenient laundry, plus a detached one-car garage. The layout offers straightforward, practical living with easy access to local shops and services. Ideal for someone seeking a well-maintained, self-contained residence in the Lake Mills area.

Apartment for rent at Tamarack Gardens-Fox Hills, 227-235 Tamarack Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/10

Managed by Tamarack Gardens-Fox Hills Apartments

$1,625 - $1,650

Apartment2 Beds1.5 Baths1,150 ft²

Tamarack Gardens-Fox Hills

227-235 Tamarack Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551

Amenities: Oven. Apartment for rent in Lake Mills for $1,625-$1,650 with 2 beds, 1.5 baths, 1,150 sqft and located within Tamarack Gardens-Fox Hills at 227-235 Tamarack Dr in Lake Mills, WI 53551.

Apartment for rent at White Oak Estates, 1348 S Main St, Lake Mills, WI 53551

1/10

Managed by White Oak Estates

$2,200

Apartment3 Beds2.5 Baths1,895 ft²

White Oak Estates

1348 S Main St, Lake Mills, WI 53551

Spacious 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath apartment in Lake Mills, WI offering an in-unit washer and dryer, private entry, and a two-car attached garage. The layout provides comfortable living areas and convenient storage, while the private entry adds direct access and privacy. Ideal for those seeking a well-equipped residence with practical amenities in a convenient location.

More rentals near 53551

House for rent at 208 Tansdale Court, Johnson Creek, WI 53038

1/10

Featured

Managed by Lanette Robson

$3,295

House5 Beds3.5 Baths2,752 ft²

208 Tansdale Court

Johnson Creek, WI 53038

Welcome home to this beautiful and spacious 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath single-family home located on a quiet cul-de-sac in the desirable community of Johnson Creek. With generous living space, an attached garage, and a finished walk-out basement, this home offers the perfect combination of comfort, functionality, and style. The main level features an open and inviting floor plan with abundant natural light, spacious living areas, and a well-appointed kitchen ideal for everyday living and entertaining. The large primary suite includes a private bath, while four additional bedrooms provide plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office.

6.9 miles away

Apartment for rent at Deer Creek 2, 113 Deer Creek Court, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

Price cut $75

Managed by Real Estate Specialists

$1,175

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath1,200 ft²

Deer Creek 2

113 Deer Creek Court, Jefferson, WI 53549

Spacious kitchen and living room with an open warm concept. 2 bedroom 1 bath. 1 car detached garage with an extra surface parking spot. Amenities: Range.

7 miles away

Apartment for rent at Meadow Estates, 739 Masonic Blvd, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

Managed by Bielinski Management

$1,350 - $1,525

Apartment1-2 Beds1 Bath720-940 ft²

Meadow Estates

739 Masonic Blvd, Jefferson, WI 53549

Meadow Estates offers brand-new apartment living in Jefferson, featuring thoughtfully designed one- and two-bedroom residences in a calm, contemporary setting. Interiors are designed with everyday comfort in mind, featuring refined, durable finishes, well-planned kitchens with generous storage, and in-unit washers and dryers for added convenience. Private outdoor spaces-decks in upper apartments and patios on lower levels-extend your living space and create an inviting connection to the outdoors. With smart layouts, modern design, and a welcoming residential feel, Meadow Estates delivers comfortable, low-maintenance living in a desirable Jefferson location. Amenities: Private Entry.

7.2 miles away

Apartment for rent at The Ponds, 175-200 Pondview Dr, Johnson Creek, WI 53038

1/10

Managed by Northern Management

$1,799 - $2,099

Apartment2-3 Beds1-2 Baths1,196-1,446 ft²

The Ponds

175-200 Pondview Dr, Johnson Creek, WI 53038

Imagine a life where convenience meets comfort. At The Ponds in Johnson Creek, WI, that's exactly what you'll find. Our prime location near Interstate 94 & Hwy. 26 makes commuting a breeze, whether you're traveling to Madison or Milwaukee, while also keeping you close to everyday essentials like shopping, restaurants, schools, and parks. This charming apartment complex offers spacious one, two, & three bedroom units with a private balcony or patio for enjoying the outdoors. Each unit comes with an attached garage for convenient parking and extra storage space.

7.2 miles away

Apartment for rent at Racine Street Townhomes, 719 721 W Racine St, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

Price cut $75

Managed by Racine Street Townhomes

$1,250

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath

Racine Street Townhomes

719 721 W Racine St, Jefferson, WI 53549

Discover this two-bedroom, one-bath apartment in Jefferson, WI, featuring an in-unit washer and dryer for convenient laundry and off-street parking. The layout offers practical living space and dependable amenities in a residential setting. Located in Jefferson, the unit provides easy access to local services and travel routes.

7.3 miles away

Apartment for rent at The Barrel Yards of Cambridge, 900 Vineyard Dr, Cambridge, WI 53523

1/10

Featured

Managed by Cambridge Drive

$1,350 - $2,025

ApartmentStudio-2 Beds1-2 Baths700-1,100 ft²

The Barrel Yards of Cambridge

900 Vineyard Dr, Cambridge, WI 53523

Welcome to The Barrel Yards, where affordable elegance meets small-town charm in Cambridge, Wisconsin. Phase 1 is now complete, featuring 22 stunning studio, one-bedroom, and two-bedroom residences. Each apartment is thoughtfully designed with in-unit washer/dryer, heated underground parking, individual storage units, luxury plank flooring, soft-close cabinetry, and airy vaulted ceilings for exceptional comfort and style. Enjoy picturesque views-north-facing units overlook the lush vineyards of Cambridge Winery and the iconic Dancing Goat distillery, while south-facing homes offer tranquil woodland scenes.

7.4 miles away

Apartment for rent at 417 & 421 N Elizabeth Ave, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

Managed by 417 N Elizabeth

$1,020

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath

417 & 421 N Elizabeth Ave

Jefferson, WI 53549

If you're looking for small town atmosphere just minutes away from Madison you'll love our apartment community at, 417 N Elizabeth St, in Jefferson, Wisconsin. 417 N Elizabeth St LLC Apartments are conveniently located on a quiet side street that is within walking distance to the downtown area and Jefferson County Fair. All of our apartments are very clean and well maintained 1-2 bedroom units. Each unit includes a Stove, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Garbage Disposal, Air Conditioning, and storage units. In each building there are Coin operated washer and dryer located in the basements.

7.5 miles away

Apartment for rent at Jefferson Schoolhouse Apartment Homes, 201 S Copeland Ave, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

New 2 days ago

Managed by Jefferson Schoolhouse Apartment Homes, Jshah

$939

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath750 ft²

Jefferson Schoolhouse Apartment Homes

201 S Copeland Ave, Jefferson, WI 53549

Remember When.you had to go to your homeroom before classes? or when you had to go to the blackboard and write I will not chew gum in class 10 times? Perhaps you were the type of student who performed on stage in the auditorium or spent dreadful time in the principal's office. Now your homeroom can be your bedroom. Chewing gum can be written on your own blackboard grocery list. Live in the principal's office drinking fine wine or relax on your sofa in a gymnasium apartment.

7.7 miles away

Apartment for rent at 166 N Main St, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

Managed by BlackRidge Leasing

$2,095

Apartment3 Beds2 Baths1,733 ft²

166 N Main St

Jefferson, WI 53549

Spacious, newly renovated 3 bedroom, 2 bath lower duplex unit with over 1,700 sq ft of living space. Features an attached garage, in-unit laundry, and a master bedroom with its own private bathroom. Water is included, and tenant is responsible for all other utilities. Lease is 12 months, and pets are welcome, a $200 refundable pet deposit applies, with the landlord allowing 1 small dog under 25 lbs (non-vicious breeds) or up to 2 cats, plus an additional $40/month per animal. Tenant is responsible for snow removal for their parking space and private walkway. Please note, all photos are edited.

7.7 miles away

Apartment for rent at Hunters Glen, 101 Deer Crossing, Johnson Creek, WI 53038

1/10

Managed by Real Estate Specialists

$1,800

Apartment3 Beds2 Baths1,550 ft²

Hunters Glen

101 Deer Crossing, Johnson Creek, WI 53038

Johnson Creek Condo Style Apartment. Beautiful country living, 3 bedroom, 2 bath, 2 car attached garage. Freeway access, midpoint between Madison and Milwaukee, next to schools. Amenities: Range.

7.7 miles away

Apartment for rent at Riverfront, 411 S Wisconsin Dr, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

Managed by The Riverfront Apartments

$1,349

Apartment3 Beds2 Baths1,110 ft²

Riverfront

411 S Wisconsin Dr, Jefferson, WI 53549

Apartment for rent in Jefferson for $1,349 with 3 beds, 2 baths, 1,110 sqft and located within Riverfront at 411 S Wisconsin Dr in Jefferson, WI 53549.

7.8 miles away

Apartment for rent at 113 E Milwaukee St, Jefferson, WI 53549

1/10

Managed by SRB Property Management

$1,095

Apartment2 Beds2 Baths

113 E Milwaukee St

Jefferson, WI 53549

Discover downtown Jefferson living in this freshly remodeled 2-bedroom, 2-bath apartment with a private entry. The home features an in-unit washer and dryer and bright interiors that showcase the recent updates. Located within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and parks, this unit offers convenient access to local amenities while providing a standalone entrance for added privacy. At SRB Property Management, we strive to provide an experience that is cost-effective and convenient. That's why we provide a Resident Benefits Package (RBP) to address common headaches for our residents and provide must-have services for our renters.

7.8 miles away

Viewing 1-20 of 20 rentals in and near 53551

What to Know About

Life in Lake Mills & Beyond

Lake Mills shares many of the great qualities that make Wisconsin a desirable place to live.

Wisconsin, known for its picturesque landscapes, vibrant cities, and fascinating history, is a true gem of the Midwest. Discover Wisconsin's rich heritage by visiting its state-of-the-art museums, such as the Wisconsin Historical Museum in Madison or the Milwaukee Public Museum, or enroll in prestigious universities like the University of Wisconsin-Madison, Marquette University, and the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. The industries of manufacturing, agriculture, and tourism have built a robust economy in Wisconsin.

Combined with its diverse geography, it offers endless opportunities for outdoor enthusiasts to explore the state's stunning natural beauty. Enjoy fishing in the Great Lakes, skiing in its scenic mountains, or hiking in the picturesque Kettle Moraine State Forest. Cheer for the Green Bay Packers (NFL) and the Milwaukee Bucks (NBA), or take a scenic drive through the charming towns and countryside. And make sure to take advantage of famous attractions like Lambeau Field, Ice Age National Scientific Reserve, and the Wisconsin Dells.

Experience the best of both worlds with Wisconsin's unique blend of outdoor recreation and thriving economy, making it a great place to live.

Rental Market Trends

Lake Mills, WI

View full report

As of October 2026, Lake Mills's rental market is stable, with rentals spending about 36 days on the market, about the same as in Wisconsin (36), and rents about flat over the past year. Lake Mills's average rent is 9.6% ($145) higher than the Wisconsin average of $1,506 and 20.7% ($431) lower than the U.S. average of $2,082.

Average Rent

$1,651

Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change

0.06% ($1)

Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change

0.1% ($2)

Days on Market

Unit Type	Average Rent	Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change	Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
1 Bed	$1,383	0.14% ($2)	1.5% ($21)
2 Beds	$1,710	0.43% ($7)	0.1% ($1)
3 Beds	$2,208	0.43% ($10)	0.6% ($12)

Nearby Cities	Average Rent	Avg. Rent vs. Lake MillsAverage Rent vs. Lake Mills	Days on Market
Waterloo	$1,179	28.6% ($472)	34 days
Johnson Creek	$1,682	1.9% ($31)	33 days
Cambridge	$1,638	0.8% ($13)	28 days
Deerfield	$1,626	1.5% ($25)	28 days
Jefferson	$1,346	18.5% ($305)	36 days

Based on rentals advertised on RentalSource in and around Lake Mills.

Frequently Asked Questions

Lake Mills Rental Market FAQs

Explore rental prices, market conditions, and affordability in Lake Mills, WI.

What is the average rent in Lake Mills, WI?

The average rent in Lake Mills, WI is about $1,651 per month.

What is the average rent for different bedroom sizes in Lake Mills, WI?

In Lake Mills, the average rent is about $1,383 per month for a 1-bedroom home, about $1,710 for a 2-bedroom home and about $2,208 for a 3-bedroom home.

How do rent prices in Lake Mills, WI compare with the national average?

The average rent in Lake Mills is 20.7% ($431) lower than the national average of $2,082 per month.

How competitive is the rental market in Lake Mills, WI?

The rental market in Lake Mills, WI is currently stable, with rentals spending about 36 days on the market, about the same as in Wisconsin (36), and rents about flat over the past year.

Can I afford to rent a home in Lake Mills, WI?

Based on the current averages, a household would need an annual income of about $68,400 to comfortably afford a 2-bedroom home in Lake Mills.

What's New on the Blog

Explore recent posts on our blog, curated for renters, landlords, and industry pros.