Find Rentals in Middlebury

Homes for Rent Houses for Rent Apartments for Rent See Newest Listings

Explore Listings

Browse Rentals Browse Houses Browse Apartments

Market Trends

Rental Market Trends Hottest Rental Markets

Property Managers

List Your Rentals Property Manager Directory Listings Quality Policy

Renter Resources

Rent Calculator Rent vs. Buy Calculator Moving Center Search with AI Avoid Rental Scams

Help & Support

Blog FAQs About Us Contact Us

Save homes you like and get email alerts for new listings.

Filters Save search Homes for you

Apartments for Rent in Middlebury, IN

Showing 1 rental in Middlebury, then 19 more within 25 miles, nearest first.

1-20 of 20 rentals

Apartment for rent at 818 Antler Dr, Middlebury, IN 46540

1/10

Managed by Property Management Services

$1,320

Apartment3 Beds1 Bath

818 Antler Dr

Middlebury, IN 46540

Welcome to our spacious 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment in Middlebury, IN. No hot summers for you and your family in this 3 bedroom 1 bathroom apartment that has central air. Located in Middlebury close to Meadow Valley Golf Club, this property comes with convenient in unit washer/dryer hook ups, stove, refrigerator and dishwasher for easy after meal clean up. 1 stall attached garage can be used for extra storage or opt to dodge the winter's snow. Tenants in lower units responsible for mowing, lawn care, bushes, leaves, weeds. All tenants responsible to remove snow. Sorry, no pets permitted and smoking is prohibited.

More rentals near Middlebury

Apartment for rent at 1007 Zollinger Rd, Goshen, IN 46528

1/10

Managed by Property Management Services

$1,250

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath

1007 Zollinger Rd

Goshen, IN 46528

Introducing our 2 Bedroom Duplex tucked away in Goshen, IN. This cozy duplex features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, perfect for those seeking a comfortable living space. Residence has a private entrance and the living room lets the sunshine in featuring a double window with stained trim. This unit features beautiful dark vinyl flooring throughout makes for easy cleaning. Appliances included are stove and refrigerator with decorate tile behind the stove. The kitchen also features bright white laminated cabinets to store all your dishes and smaller appliances. The wrap around counter for additional entertaining or kitchen prep space.

7.9 miles away

Apartment for rent at 505 Middlebury St, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Managed by Property Management Services

$995

Apartment3 Beds1 Bath

505 Middlebury St

Goshen, IN 46526

Welcome to our 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment located in the charming town of Goshen, IN. Just 4 minutes from the shops and restaurants from Downtown Goshen, this cozy unit features a mix of stunning dark vinyl flooring and plush carpet for your comfort. The kitchen comes equipped with essential appliances such as a stove, refrigerator, and dishwasher, making meal preparation a breeze. For parking, there are 2 spaces in the back of building in a single row. If you have guests, they will have to park on the side street.

8.5 miles away

Apartment for rent at 251 Woodridge Court, Goshen, IN 46528

1/10

Managed by Property Management Services

$1,295

Apartment3 Beds1 Bath1,034 ft²

251 Woodridge Court

Goshen, IN 46528

Welcome to our spacious 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment located in Goshen, IN. Near Wasabi Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi, this home features beautiful wood look, easy to clean flooring. Inside, you'll find central heat and air to keep you cozy throughout those hot summers and harsh winters. The kitchen comes equipped with a stove, refrigerator, and dishwasher making meal prep and clean up a dream. Enjoy the convenience of washer/dryer hookups in the unit. With exterior care is included, you can spend your time relaxing instead of worrying about maintenance. Have a furry friend you want to bring along?

8.5 miles away

Apartment for rent at 201 Olive St, Goshen, IN 46528

1/10

Managed by Property Management Services

$1,125 - $1,150

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath

201 Olive St

Goshen, IN 46528

Welcome to the 2 bedroom duplex in Goshen. Just 3 minutes from the shops and restaurants of downtown Goshen, this cozy apartment features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, perfect for those seeking a comfortable living space. The unit comes equipped with essential appliances such as a refrigerator, stove, and dishwasher, making meal preparation a breeze. Stay cool during the warmer months with central air conditioning. For added convenience, there are washer/dryer hook-ups available in the unit. Please note that this apartment does not allow pets and no smoking is permitted.

8.7 miles away

Apartment for rent at 54686 County Rd 19 #3X2N, Bristol, IN 46507

1/10

Listed by Matthew McKenzie

$1,099

Apartment3 Beds2 Baths

54686 County Rd 19 #3X2N

Bristol, IN 46507

XTSY7GW4. Tired of living in an apartment with folks above, below, and on the sides of you? Tired of communal areas putting your health at risk in today's pandemic world? Want to have your own yard? Want to have your own home? Let us assist you in getting you what you want. We Have the HOME for YOU. Move into a great community and fabulous home today and leave the apartment life behind. Amenities: Range/Oven & Near Parks. Heating: forced air. Flooring: softwood.

8.7 miles away

Apartment for rent at 401 1/2 Queen St, Goshen, IN 46528

1/10

Managed by 5-Star Property Managers

$600

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath810 ft²

401 1/2 Queen St

Goshen, IN 46528

1-Bedroom Apartment. 1-Bathroom. on Street Parking. Gas & Electric Not Included in Rent; Add $115/Month for Gas & Electric; Any Overages will be Charged to Tenant. Water & Sewer Not Included in Rent; Add $30/Month for Water & Sewer; Any Overages will be Charged to Tenant. Lawn Care Included in Rent. Tenant Responsible for Snow Removal. 1-Year Lease and Security Deposit Required. After Application and Background Review We Will Contact You.

8.9 miles away

Apartment for rent at 311 1/2 S, Goshen, IN 46528

1/7

Managed by MBSR Rentals

$800

$844.45/mo with required fees

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath500 ft²

311 1/2 S

Goshen, IN 46528

Welcome to 311 1/2 South 10th Street in Goshen, IN. This cozy apartment features 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom, perfect for those seeking a comfortable living space. The unit comes equipped with tenant controlled baseboard heaters to keep you warm during the colder months, as well as a window A/C unit for your convenience. Enjoy the natural light that filters through the blinds, and make use of the sliding double closet doors for ample storage space. The kitchen includes a microwave for easy meal preparation. Lease Terms - 1 Year.

9 miles away

Apartment for rent at 118 S 6th St, Goshen, IN 46528

1/10

Managed by Property Management Services

$735

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath

118 S 6th St

Goshen, IN 46528

Welcome to our cozy 1 bedroom, 1 bath main level apartment located in the heart of Goshen, IN. Just down the road from the shops and restaurants of downtown Goshen, this charming unit features stunning bay windows, allowing for plenty of natural night in the living room. The living room has a large bay window that is makes this apartment bright lit and special. The kitchen comes equipped with a stove and refrigerator, making meal preparation a breeze and features dark cabinets. Tenant will be responsible for removing snow from walkways however owner will complete mowing/lawn care.

9.1 miles away

Apartment for rent at 317 S 5th St #2, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Price cut $50

Managed by 5-Star Property Managers

$900

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath890 ft²

317 S 5th St #2

Goshen, IN 46526

2-Bedroom Apartment. 1-Bathroom. Tenant Must Have Electric Transferred Into Their Name. Rent Does not Include Water & Sewer; Add $35/month for 1-Person; Add $45/month for 2-People. Rent Does not Include Gas Utility for Heat; Add $70/month. Refrigerator. Electric Oven. Lawn Care Included in Rent. Goshen School District. No Pets Allowed. Absolutely No Smoking Permitted in Home or on Property. 1-Year Lease and Security Deposit Required. After Application and Background Review We Will Contact You.

9.3 miles away

Apartment for rent at 110 E Monroe #B, Goshen, IN 46526

1/7

Price cut $25

Managed by 5-Star Property Managers

$875

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath700 ft²

110 E Monroe #B

Goshen, IN 46526

2-Bedroom Apartment. 1-Bathroom. Tenants must have Gas & Electric and Water & Sewer Transferred into Their Name. Refrigerator. Oven/Range. Hardwood Floors Throughout. Central AC. Lawn Care Provided. Tenant Responsible for Snow Removal. Washer/Dryer Provided (Tenant Responsible for Maintenance) 1-Year Lease and Security Deposit Required. After Application and Background Review We Will Contact You.

9.4 miles away

Apartment for rent at 813 S 8th, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Managed by Property Management Services

$695

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath

813 S 8th

Goshen, IN 46526

Check out this 1 bedroom 1 bathroom apartment in Goshen. Just 1 minute from Water Tower Park, this property features modern wood vinyl flooring throughout. In the kitchen, you're equipped with a stove and refrigerator for all your meal prepping needs. If washer/dryer is present at move in, tenant is accepting them as is. Owner will not repair or replace. Please note garage behind building is NOT for tenant use. With no pets and no smoking permitted, you can rest easy knowing your home will be clean and well-maintained. Owner will complete all exterior care. Tenant only responsible for snow removal.

9.5 miles away

Apartment for rent at 523 S Main St, Goshen, IN 46526

1/9

New 8 hours ago

Managed by 5-Star Property Managers

$900

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath1,072 ft²

523 S Main St

Goshen, IN 46526

2-Bedroom Apartment. Attached Single Car Garage. Off Street Parking Available. Unfinished basement. Tenants Must Have Gas and Electric Transferred Into Their Name. Water & Sewer Usage Not Included In Rent; Add $50/Month for 1-Person; Add $60/Month for 2-People; Water & Sewer Utility will be Separated Out in Lease; Any Overages will be Billed to Tenant. Refrigerator. Gas Oven. Full size Washer/Dryer (Gas & Electric) hook-up. Lawn Care Included in Rent. Tenant Must Provide Snow Removal. Absolutely No Smoking in Apartment or on Property. Absolutely No Pets Allowed. 1-Year Lease and Security Deposit Required.

9.5 miles away

Apartment for rent at 1601 S 8th St #1, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Featured

Managed by 5-Star Property Managers

$1,200

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath1,790 ft²

1601 S 8th St #1

Goshen, IN 46526

Beautiful Recently Renovated Large 2-BR Apartment in Goshen's Historic South Side. Main Level Apartment. Hardwood Floors. 9'-8 High Ceilings. 2-Fireplaces. 2-Bedrooms. Full Bathroom. Living Room. Sitting Room. Sun Room. All New Windows. Brand New Efficient Hot Water Boiler Heating System with Thermostat. Refrigerator. Electric Oven/Range. (3) Window A/C Units. Gas & Electric Usage Not Included in Rent; Add $240/Month; Gas & Electric Utility will be Separated In Lease and any Overage Will be Billed to Tenant.

9.9 miles away

Apartment for rent at 1006 S Indiana Ave #204, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Managed by Bontrager Realty

$1,450

Apartment1 Bed1 Bath935 ft²

1006 S Indiana Ave #204

Goshen, IN 46526

1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom - 935 sq. ft. open concept floor plan. Stainless steel kitchen appliances and granite countertops. 9 foot ceilings and luxury vinyl plank flooring. Washer & dryer included in apt. Water/Sewer utilities included in rent. Spacious bedroom with large window and walk-in closet. Walking distance to downtown Goshen and Shanklin Park/Pool. Conveniently located across from Goshen Middle School. Amenities: Central HVAC, Range & On-Demand Water Heater.

10.2 miles away

Apartment for rent at 1006 S Indiana Ave #512, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Managed by Bontrager Realty

$1,895

Apartment2 Beds2 Baths1,320 ft²

1006 S Indiana Ave #512

Goshen, IN 46526

2 Bedrooms & 2 Full Bathrooms - with attached XL garage. Stainless steel kitchen appliances and granite countertops. 9 foot ceilings and luxury vinyl plank flooring. Washer & dryer included in apt. Water/Sewer utilities included in rent. Spacious bedrooms with large windows and walk-in closets. Walking distance to downtown Goshen and Shanklin Park/Pool. Conveniently located across from Goshen Middle School. Amenities: Central HVAC, Range & On-Demand Water Heater.

10.2 miles away

Apartment for rent at 1006 S Indiana Ave #303, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Managed by Bontrager Realty

$1,825

Apartment2 Beds1.5 Baths1,254 ft²

1006 S Indiana Ave #303

Goshen, IN 46526

2 Bedroom 1.5 Bathroom - 1,254 sq. ft. open concept split bedroom floor plan with attached garage. Stainless steel kitchen appliances and granite countertops. 9 foot ceilings and luxury vinyl plank flooring. Washer & dryer included in apt. Water/Sewer utilities included in rent. Spacious bedrooms with large windows and walk-in closets. Walking distance to downtown Goshen and Shanklin Park. Conveniently located across from Goshen Middle School. Amenities: Central HVAC, Range & On-Demand Water Heater.

10.3 miles away

Apartment for rent at 433 S Silverwood Lane #6, Goshen, IN 46526

1/8

New 8 hours ago

Managed by 5-Star Property Managers

$825

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath685 ft²

433 S Silverwood Lane #6

Goshen, IN 46526

2-Bedroom Apartment. Storage Shed. Tenant Must Have Gas/Electric Transferred into their Name. Water & Sewer Usage not Included in Rent; Add $45/Month for 1-Person; Add $60/Month for 2-People; Utility will be Separated In Lease; Any Utility Overage Will be Billed to Tenant. Apartment Complex Parking with Parking Permit Required (No More Than 2 Standard Vehicles Allowed); 1-Person on Lease only 1 Permit will Be Authorized; Tenant Responsible for $10 per Permit at Move-In. Central AC. Refrigerator. Gas Oven/Range. Lawn Care Included in Rent. Washer/Dryer Hook-Up (Gas & Electric) Absolutely No Pets Allowed. Absolutely No Smoking in Apartment or on Property.

10.4 miles away

Apartment for rent at 213 Tanglewood Dr #A, Goshen, IN 46526

1/10

Managed by 5-Star Property Managers

$925

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath982 ft²

213 Tanglewood Dr #A

Goshen, IN 46526

2 Bedroom. 1 Bathroom. Tenants Must Have Gas & Electric and Water & Sewer Transferred into their Name. Refrigerator. Electric Oven/Range. Full Size Washer/Dryer Hookup (Gas or Electric) Forced Air Gas Furnace. Central AC. Storage Shed. Lawn Care Provided. Snow Removal Provided. Goshen School Districts. Absolutely No Smoking Allowed. Absolutely No Pets Allowed. 1-Year Lease and Security Deposit Required. Amenities: After Application and Background Review We Will Contact You & Tenants Must Have Gas/Electric and Water/Sewer Transferred into their Name.

10.8 miles away

Apartment for rent at 200 Meadow Lane, Constantine, MI 49042

1/10

Listed by a leasing agent

$747

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath

200 Meadow Lane

Constantine, MI 49042

We are confident that you will find Elm Tree Apartments every bit as endearing as the town its located in. We pay for water, sewage, and trash removal. Great management and maintenance staff. We take pride in our communication between residents and staff. Built in 1983, we provide a monthly newsletter filled with exciting news and events. Barrier free apartments on site. Rent based on income. This institution is an equal opportunity provider. Esta instituci - n es un proveedor de servicios con igualdad de oportunidades.

10.9 miles away

Viewing 1-20 of 20 rentals in and near Middlebury

What to Know About

Life in Middlebury & Beyond

Middlebury shares many of the great qualities that make Indiana a desirable place to live.

Indiana is where the past meets the present, and the great outdoors is right at your fingertips. Get to know the rich cultural heritage of this Midwestern gem by visiting incredible museums like the Eiteljorg Museum of American Indians and Western Art, or check out the top universities like Purdue University and Indiana University. Indiana is a hub of economic activity, with its thriving manufacturing, agriculture, and transportation industries.

The state also offers plenty of opportunities for those seeking adventure and excitement. From exploring the beautiful state parks to fishing in its many lakes and rivers, Indiana is a nature-lovers paradise from the Hoosier National Forest to the Ohio River. And for sports fans, check out the Indianapolis Colts (NFL) and Indiana Pacers (NBA) or catch a game at universities like Purdue or Indiana. In addition, discover famous attractions like the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, home of the world-famous Indianapolis 500 race, the Children's Museum of Indianapolis, and the historic town of Brown County.

With its strong economy, quality education, and lively atmosphere, Indiana is the perfect place to live.

Rental Market Trends

Middlebury, IN

As of November 2026, Middlebury's rental market is stable, with rentals spending about 26 days on the market, about the same as in Indiana (27), and rents up 6.1% over the past year. Middlebury's average rent is 3.4% ($50) higher than the Indiana average of $1,452 and 26.2% ($534) lower than the U.S. average of $2,036.

Average Rent

$1,502

Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change

0.76% ($11)

Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change

6.1% ($86)

Days on Market

Unit Type	Average Rent	Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change	Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
1 Bed	$1,002	1.00% ($10)	5.4% ($51)
2 Beds	$1,367	0.50% ($7)	7.3% ($92)
3 Beds	$1,874	0.71% ($13)	3.2% ($58)

Nearby Cities	Average Rent	Avg. Rent vs. MiddleburyAverage Rent vs. Middlebury	Days on Market
Bristol	$1,338	10.9% ($164)	26 days
White Pigeon	$1,707	13.6% ($205)	24 days
Goshen	$1,262	16.0% ($240)	26 days
Constantine	$1,026	31.7% ($476)	26 days
Elkhart	$1,144	23.8% ($358)	24 days

Based on rentals advertised on RentalSource in and around Middlebury.

Frequently Asked Questions

Middlebury Rental Market FAQs

Explore rental prices, market conditions, and affordability in Middlebury, IN.

What is the average rent in Middlebury, IN?

The average rent in Middlebury, IN is about $1,502 per month.

What is the average rent for different bedroom sizes in Middlebury, IN?

In Middlebury, the average rent is about $1,002 per month for a 1-bedroom apartment, about $1,367 for a 2-bedroom apartment and about $1,874 for a 3-bedroom apartment.

How do rent prices in Middlebury, IN compare with the national average?

The average rent in Middlebury is 26.2% ($534) lower than the national average of $2,036 per month.

How competitive is the rental market in Middlebury, IN?

The rental market in Middlebury, IN is currently stable, with rentals spending about 26 days on the market, about the same as in Indiana (27), and rents up 6.1% over the past year.

Can I afford to rent an apartment in Middlebury, IN?

Based on the current averages, a household would need an annual income of about $54,700 to comfortably afford a 2-bedroom apartment in Middlebury.

What's New on the Blog

Explore recent posts on our blog, curated for renters, landlords, and industry pros.