Find Rentals in Sheffield Lake

Explore Listings

Browse Apartments

Property Managers

List Your Rentals

Listings Quality Policy

Renter Resources

Avoid Scams & Fraud

Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Rent Affordability Calculator

Help & Support

Filters Save Search Homes For You

Homes & Apartments for Rent in Sheffield Lake, OH

1-5 of 5 rentals

House for rent at 638 Treadyway Blvd, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by DeAnna Property Management

$1,650

House2 Beds1 Bath975 ft²

638 Treadyway Blvd

Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

Experience the comfort of first-floor living in this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom, non-smoking home. The large kitchen features beautiful white shaker-style cabinets and stainless steel appliances, including a refrigerator, glass-top stove, dishwasher and microwave. The open living area offers plenty of closet space and there is an attached 1-car garage. Luxury vinyl flooring runs throughout the property. Both bedrooms come with spacious closets and washer/dryer hookups are available. Small dog. No Cats. This property is part of the Treadway Ponds Hoa, which covers all snow removal and lawn care.

1 / 10

Managed by CLE Turnkey Real Estate

$950

Apartment2 Beds1 Bath800 ft²

5216 E Lake Rd

Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

Welcome to 5216 E. Lake Road, presented by CLE Turnkey Real Estate. We have several units available for lease. For more information and to schedule a showing, please contact us. Refrigerator, Stove, Dishwasher, Water, Sewer, Trash, Gas & Built in A/C UNit.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Landlord Leasing

$1,495

House3 Beds1 Bath912 ft²

4252 Belle Ave

Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

Freshly updated three-bedroom ranch in Sheffield Lake. As you enter the front door, you'll find a bright living room with a large picture window, fresh paint and brand-new carpeting. The adjoining dining area leads to the updated kitchen featuring new cabinets and updated finishes. Down the hall are three bedrooms, an updated full bathroom with a new vanity and a combination of new carpet and hardwood flooring. Neutral colors and replacement vinyl windows help create a clean, move-in-ready feel throughout the home. Outside, you'll find a detached two-car garage, partially fenced backyard and plenty of outdoor space to enjoy.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Jehan Strickland

$1,799

House3 Beds2 Baths1,520 ft²

870 Robinwood Ave

Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

Beautifully Renovated Ranch. Spacious and bright living room with newer carpet and bay window. Dining room is conveniently located off the kitchen. The eat in kitchen offers newer countertops, stainless steel appliances and plenty of cabinet space. 2 renovated bathrooms with newer floors and updated fixtures. 3 good sized bedrooms with adequate closet space. The family room offers additional living space, decorative fireplace and access to the back patio. Laundry Room. Attached 2 car garage. Private back yard. Pets Case By Case. Pet Friendly, Dogs ok & Cats ok.

1 / 9

New - 2 days ago

Managed by J & J ENTERPRISE

$1,395

House3 Beds1 Bath912 ft²

345 Lynne Dr

Sheffield Lake, OH 44054

Freshly painted and thoughtfully updated, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home in Sheffield Lake offers new carpeting and vinyl flooring throughout. Located in Sheffield Lake. Hablamos Espaol. Freshly Painted, New Carpeting And Vinyl Flooring, 3 Bedoom, One Bathroom, Sheffield Lake & hablamos Espanol.

Viewing 1-5 of 5 rentals in Sheffield Lake

What to Know About

Life in Sheffield Lake & Beyond

Sheffield Lake shares many of the great qualities that make Ohio a desirable place to live.

Ohio has rolling hills, scenic countryside, and friendly people. Immerse yourself in Ohio's cultural heritage by visiting iconic sites like the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Cincinnati Museum Center, and the National Museum of the United States Air Force. Ohio is also home to renowned universities like Ohio State University and the University of Cincinnati, where you can take your knowledge further. In addition, the economy of Ohio is thriving with solid manufacturing, finance, and healthcare industries.

It's also a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts with its picturesque parks and recreational areas, such as the Hocking Hills, the Cuyahoga Valley National Park, and the Great Lakes. Ohio is also home to several sports teams, including the Cleveland Browns (NFL), Cincinnati Bengals (NFL), Cleveland Indians (MLB), Cincinnati Reds (MLB), and Cleveland Cavaliers (NBA). In addition, discover iconic attractions like the Pro Football Hall of Fame, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Columbus Zoo, and Cincinnati Zoo.

Whether you are looking for a bustling city or quiet countryside, Ohio has something for everyone, making it a great place to live.

Rental Market Trends

Sheffield Lake, OH

As of June 2026, Sheffield Lake's rental market is competitive, with strong renter demand causing quick leasing times for well-priced units. Sheffield Lake's average rent is 14.6% ($189) lower than the Ohio average of $1,296 and 38.4% ($690) lower than the U.S. average of $1,797.

Average Rent

$1,107

Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change

40.6% ($758)

Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change

40.6% ($758)

Avg. Days on MarketAverage Days on Market

Unit Type	Average Rent	Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change	Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
1 Bed	$777	36.6% ($448)	36.6% ($448)
2 Beds	$993	34.5% ($522)	34.5% ($522)
3 Beds	$1,108	41% ($770)	41% ($770)

Nearby Cities	Average Rent	Avg. Rent vs. Sheffield LakeAverage Rent vs. Sheffield Lake	Avg. Days on MarketAverage Days on Market
Lorain	$1,027	7.2% ($80)	35 days
Avon	$2,339	111.3% ($1232)	30 days
Elyria	$917	17.2% ($190)	31 days
Westlake	$1,107	No change	38 days
North Olmsted	$1,247	12.6% ($140)	34 days

Rental market trends are calculated using listing data from RentalSource.

Frequently Asked Questions

Sheffield Lake Rental Market FAQs

Explore rental prices, market trends, and availability in Sheffield Lake, OH.

What is the average rent in Sheffield Lake, OH?

The average rent in Sheffield Lake, OH is $1,107 per month.

What is the rental price range for homes in Sheffield Lake, OH?

Homes in Sheffield Lake typically rent for between $600 and $1,440 per month, with an average of $1,107 per month.

What is the average rent for different bedroom sizes in Sheffield Lake, OH?

In Sheffield Lake, the average rent for a 1-bedroom home is $777 per month, for a 2-bedroom home, $993 per month, and a 3-bedroom home is $1,108 per month.

How do rent prices in Sheffield Lake, OH compare with the national average?

The average rent in Sheffield Lake is 38.4% ($690) lower than the national average of $1,797 per month.

How have rent prices in Sheffield Lake, OH changed recently?

The average rent in Sheffield Lake has decreased by 40.6% ($758) in the last month and decreased by 40.6% ($758) over the past year.

How competitive is the rental market in Sheffield Lake, OH?

The rental market in Sheffield Lake, OH, is currently competitive, with strong renter demand causing quick leasing times for well-priced units.

How long do rentals stay on the market in Sheffield Lake, OH?

In Sheffield Lake, OH, the average rental stays on the market for approximately 29 days. While most properties are rented within this timeframe, factors like seasonality, demand, and property type can affect how quickly a rental leases.

How many rental properties are available in Sheffield Lake, OH?

There are currently 5 rental properties available in Sheffield Lake, OH.

Can I afford to rent a home in Sheffield Lake, OH?

Based on the current averages, a household would need an annual income of $39,720 to comfortably afford a 2-bedroom home in Sheffield Lake.