Find Rentals in Sugar City

Explore Listings

Browse Apartments

Property Managers

List Your Rentals

Listings Quality Policy

Renter Resources

Avoid Scams & Fraud

Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Rent Affordability Calculator

Help & Support

Filters Save search Homes for you

Homes & Apartments for Rent in 83448

1-15 of 15 rentals

Townhouse for rent at 686 S Cutler Ave, Sugar City, ID 83448

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Connextion Property Management

$2,250

Townhouse3 Beds2 Baths1,460 ft²

686 S Cutler Ave

Sugar City, ID 83448

Welcome to Cutler House, your new home in the heart of Sugar City, ID. This home offers a unique blend of comfort and convenience with it's top-notch amenities. Enjoy the luxury of an in-unit washer and dryer, saving you time and effort on laundry days. The home also comes with a spacious 2-car garage, providing ample space for your vehicles or additional storage. One of the standout features of Cutler House is the private fenced yard. This outdoor space is perfect for hosting small gatherings, enjoying a morning coffee or simply soaking up the sun.

1 / 10

Updated - today

Managed by Commercial Northwest Property Management

$1,649

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,556 ft²

661 Brezza Dr

Sugar City, ID 83448

Limited time only. Experience the perfect blend of small-town charm and modern living at Sugar Mill Townhomes in Sugar City, Idaho. Conveniently located just minutes from Rexburg, our thoughtfully designed townhomes offer spacious floor plans, contemporary finishes and the comfort of maintenance-free living. Each home features open-concept living spaces, fully equipped kitchens, ample storage and private entrances designed to fit your lifestyle. Residents enjoy a peaceful neighborhood setting with easy access to local shopping, dining, parks and schools, while remaining close to Brigham Young University-Idaho and major employers throughout the area.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$1,895

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,531 ft²

455 Blue Spruce Ave #112

Sugar City, ID 83448

$500 Off First Month's Rent If Signed Before The End of October. Discover Yellowstone Townhomes: where comfort meets convenience. Perfectly positioned just minutes from BYU-I and downtown Rexburg, this brand-new 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence offers an ideal home for students, families and professionals alike. The main level features a spacious, open-concept living area that flows effortlessly into an inviting eat-in kitchen, designed for both daily functionality and gathering. Convenience is key here, with a direct-entry, two-car garage and a strategically placed half bath on the main floor.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$2,795

House5 Beds4 Baths2,561 ft²

664 S Idaho Ave

Sugar City, ID 83448

Photos are of similar unit, Exact photos will be available once construction is complete. Introducing a stunning twin home in the charming town of Sugar City, Idaho. This 5-bedroom, 4-bathroom twin home boasts a modern design and is situated on a premium lot in the old farm town estates. The fully equipped kitchen features quartz countertops and a full appliance package, making meal preparation a breeze. The primary suite offers a private retreat with an en-suite bathroom complete with a dual-sink vanity, tile shower and oversized soaker tub. Additionally, the extra-large attached garage provides ample space for parking and storage.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$2,295

House3 Beds2 Baths1,669 ft²

535 S Cutler Ave

Sugar City, ID 83448

Introducing a stunning twin home in the charming town of Sugar City, Idaho. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home boasts a modern design and is situated on a premium oversized lot in the old farm town estates. The fully equipped kitchen features quartz countertops and a full appliance package, making meal preparation a breeze. The primary suite offers a private retreat with an en-suite bathroom complete with a dual-sink vanity, tile shower and oversized soaker tub. Additionally, the extra-large 2-car attached garage provides ample space for parking and storage.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$2,895

House6 Beds3 Baths2,640 ft²

503 Jeanine

Sugar City, ID 83448

Discover this brand-new 6-bedroom, 3-bath home in Sugar City, Id, offering high-end finishes and a beautiful layout designed for comfortable living. This Unit Will Be Ready To Go This Weekend, 9/25/26 and We Will Get New Pics And Video Upon Completion. There will be a fully fenced, fully landscaped yard that includes a sprinkler system and air conditioning for added convenience. Interior include top-of-the-line appliances and quality fixtures throughout, making this residence a modern and low-maintenance option in a desirable location. Contact us today at 208-782-RENT(7368) to schedule a tour and get more information.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$1,795

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,608 ft²

520 Sugar Beet Dr

Sugar City, ID 83448

Come home to this luxury 3 Bedroom 2.5 Bath townhome in Sugar City featuring high end standard finishes such as granite countertops and beautiful cabinetry throughout. This is a prime location, only one exit away from Walmart and right off Highway 20 for easy access to businesses and shopping in all directions. All the units that Gemstone Property Management is renting here at the Sugar Mill Townhomes have security doorbells, keyless entry (kwikset Smart Lock) and free 24-hour security monitoring through Evocom Security.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$1,795

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,608 ft²

566 Harvester Ave

Sugar City, ID 83448

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$1,795

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,608 ft²

541 Tiller Ave

Sugar City, ID 83448

Lease Takeover. Contact Lindsey At (406) 310-9622 For More Info. No Deposit Needed. Move Now. 3 Bed 2.5 Bath End Unit Townhome located in Sugar City. Come home to this luxury End Unit 3 Bedroom 2.5 Bath townhome in Sugar City featuring high end standard finishes such as granite countertops and beautiful cabinetry throughout. This is a prime location, only one exit away from Walmart and right off Highway 20 for easy access to businesses and shopping in all directions.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$2,795

House5 Beds4 Baths2,561 ft²

676 S Idaho Ave

Sugar City, ID 83448

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$2,395

Apartment3 Beds2 Baths1,300 ft²

271 Camas St

Sugar City, ID 83448

Welcome to L273ES, presented by Gemstone Property Management. We have several units available for lease. For more information and to schedule a showing, please contact us. Private Deck, Stove/oven, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer And Dryer Included, Internet included, All utilities included, Pantry in Kitchen, Stainless Steel Appliances, Attached 2-Car Garage, Spacious layout, Ample Storage, Modern Design, High End Finishes, No Smoking, No Cats, Dogs allowed, Tankless Water Heater, Upper Level Unit, Dog Wash Station in Mud Room, Deck Access from Kitchen and Master, Double Shower Head in Master Bath, Stackable Washer/Dryer Included & Walk-In Master Shower.

1 / 10

New - 2 days ago

Managed by Rams Nest Property Management

$1,800

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,680 ft²

540 Sugar Beet Dr

Sugar City, ID 83448

Settle into this beautifully appointed 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath townhome in the heart of Sugar City. Thoughtful touches like granite countertops and elegant cabinetry give every space a polished, move-in-ready feel. You're just minutes from Walmart with quick Highway 20 access, putting shopping, dining and local businesses all within easy reach. The kitchen comes fully equipped with a double-door refrigerator with water dispenser, electric range, stainless steel dishwasher and microwave - ready to go from day one. High-speed internet is pre-wired throughout the building and available for an additional $75/month.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Connextion Property Management

$1,800

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,630 ft²

348 S 3rd W

Sugar City, ID 83448

Welcome to Old Farm Townhomes, located in the charming Sugar City, ID. This spacious townhome offers three generously sized bedrooms and 2.5 well-appointed bathrooms. The modern interior design is sure to impress, with it's sleek lines and contemporary finishes. The convenience of washer and dryer hookups in the unit means laundry day is a breeze. Additionally, the inclusion of a one-car garage provides secure parking and additional storage space. Experience the perfect blend of comfort, style and convenience in Sugar City, ID.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$2,295

House3 Beds2 Baths1,320 ft²

505 Jeanine Dr

Sugar City, ID 83448

Brand-new 3-bedroom, 2-bath twin home in Sugar City, Id, featuring high-end finishes and an awesome layout across a comfortable floor plan. The home includes A/C, a 2-stall attached garage, washer and dryer hookups (owner may provide a set for an additional fee if desired) and all top-of-the-line appliances. There will be a fully fenced, fully landscaped yard that includes a sprinkler system. The property includes a 1,332 sq ft unfinished basement ready for your customization. Contact us today at 208-782-RENT(7368) to schedule a tour and get more information. At Gemstone Property Management, we strive to provide a cost-effective, convenient experience.

1 / 10

Featured

Managed by Gemstone Property Management

$1,795

Townhouse3 Beds2.5 Baths1,608 ft²

575 Tiller Ave

Sugar City, ID 83448

Viewing 1-15 of 15 rentals in 83448

What to Know About

Life in Sugar City & Beyond

Sugar City shares many of the great qualities that make Idaho a desirable place to live.

Idaho is the gem of the Rocky Mountains and is renowned for its jagged and majestic mountain peaks, verdant forests, and miles and miles of rolling hills. There are numerous cities and small towns throughout the state, each offering unique experiences, from the bustling capital city of Boise to the historic town of Coeur d'Alene. Immerse yourself in Idaho's rich history by exploring its many historical sites and monuments, such as the Idaho State Historical Museum and the Warhawk Air Museum, or expand your knowledge at the University of Idaho, Boise State University, and Idaho State University.

The state offers endless opportunities for outdoor recreation, from skiing or mountain biking in the Sawtooth Mountains to walking along the Snake River or fishing in the Salmon River. Explore famous attractions like the Sun Valley Resort, the Craters of the Moon National Monument, and the historic town of Wallace. Idaho's natural beauty is unparalleled, and there are many ways to experience it.

With its breathtaking landscapes, thriving economy, and endless opportunities for outdoor recreation, Idaho is the perfect place for those seeking adventure and a high quality of life.

Rental Market Trends

Sugar City, ID

As of October 2026, Sugar City's rental market is competitive, with strong renter demand causing quick leasing times for well-priced units. Sugar City's average rent is 2.2% ($35) lower than the Idaho average of $1,581 and 15.0% ($273) lower than the U.S. average of $1,819.

Average Rent

$1,546

Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change

12.2% ($214)

Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change

16.9% ($315)

Avg. Days on MarketAverage Days on Market

Unit Type	Average Rent	Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change	Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
1 Bed	$1,068	13.9% ($173)	23.8% ($334)
2 Beds	$1,266	10% ($140)	24.9% ($420)
3 Beds	$1,686	7.2% ($130)	20.7% ($441)

Nearby Cities	Average Rent	Avg. Rent vs. Sugar CityAverage Rent vs. Sugar City	Avg. Days on MarketAverage Days on Market
Rexburg	$1,041	32.7% ($505)	35 days
St. Anthony	$1,035	33.1% ($511)	39 days
Rigby	$1,388	10.2% ($158)	39 days

Rental market trends are calculated using listing data from RentalSource.

Frequently Asked Questions

Sugar City Rental Market FAQs

Explore rental prices, market trends, and availability in Sugar City, ID.

What is the average rent in Sugar City, ID?

The average rent in Sugar City, ID is $1,546 per month.

What is the rental price range for homes in Sugar City, ID?

Homes in Sugar City typically rent for between $748 and $2,192 per month, with an average of $1,546 per month.

What is the average rent for different bedroom sizes in Sugar City, ID?

In Sugar City, the average rent for a 1-bedroom home is $1,068 per month, for a 2-bedroom home, $1,266 per month, and a 3-bedroom home is $1,686 per month.

How do rent prices in Sugar City, ID compare with the national average?

The average rent in Sugar City is 15% ($273) lower than the national average of $1,819 per month.

How have rent prices in Sugar City, ID changed recently?

The average rent in Sugar City has decreased by 12.2% ($214) in the last month and decreased by 16.9% ($315) over the past year.

How competitive is the rental market in Sugar City, ID?

The rental market in Sugar City, ID, is currently competitive, with strong renter demand causing quick leasing times for well-priced units.

How long do rentals stay on the market in Sugar City, ID?

In Sugar City, ID, the average rental stays on the market for approximately 37 days. While most properties are rented within this timeframe, factors like seasonality, demand, and property type can affect how quickly a rental leases.

How many rental properties are available in Sugar City, ID?

There are currently 15 rental properties available in Sugar City, ID.

Can I afford to rent a home in Sugar City, ID?

Based on the current averages, a household would need an annual income of $50,640 to comfortably afford a 2-bedroom home in Sugar City.