3540 Caroline Ave

House
3 beds
1.5 baths
1,032 sqft
Cats & small dogs OK
W/D hookups

About 3540 Caroline Ave

Come see all this 3-Bedroom home has to offer. Conveniently located near the Indiana State Fairgrounds, this home features a comfortable layout, practical updates, and plenty of details that make everyday living easier.

Step inside to find low-maintenance LVP flooring throughout the main living areas, giving the home a clean, refreshed look. The kitchen features bright white cabinetry, with a refrigerator and stove. One of the rooms also includes a built-in desk, making it a great spot for a home office, study area, or extra workspace.

The primary bedroom offers its own attached half bathroom, complete with a vanity, sink, mirror, lighting, and toilet. Two of the bedrooms also feature brand-new carpeting for added comfort.

Laundry is convenient with full-size washer and dryer connections, so you can skip the trip to the laundromat. Parking is available on the street, with additional parking behind the home accessible from the alley.

With its updates and convenient location near the Fairgrounds, this home is worth a closer look.

Contact us today to schedule a tour. Not currently accepting Section 8 vouchers. Application Fees NON-REFUNDABLE.

Pets are welcome, but breed and weight restrictions apply. $250 Non-refundable security deposit and $50 per month, per pet. $200 Admin Fee.

Basic Qualification Criteria: 3x rent with income ratio. No felonies within the last 10 years. No evictions within the last 2 years including in process. Please visit our Qualification Criteria section for more information.

All payments related to leasing with Pillario Property Management are made exclusively to our company....
4 days on RentalSource
RentalSource last checked: 9 hours ago · Listing updated: November 13, 2026
Managed by Tiffany · (463) 295-0722
Listing data quality - We review listings daily to detect outdated, duplicate, or misleading information.

Property Summary

Property Type: House
Rental Fee: $1,200
Bedrooms: 3 beds
Bathrooms: 1.5 baths
Size: 1,032 sqft
Pets: Cats & small dogs
Laundry: Hookups
Parking: Yes
Available: Inquire
ID: 84726354

Amenities

  • Washer/Dryer Hookups
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Parking
  • Carpeted Floors
  • Refrigerator
  • Vinyl/Laminate Floors
  • Wheelchair Access

Additional Details

This 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom house at 3540 Caroline Ave in Indianapolis, IN 46218 rents for $1,200 a month. It has 1,032 square feet and is pet friendly. 3540 Caroline Ave was advertised by Tiffany on November 13, 2026.

How the Rent Compares

At $1,200 a month, this house is below the typical rent for 3-bedroom houses and townhouses in Indianapolis (about $1,500).

From 270 three-bedroom houses and townhouses listed in Indianapolis on RentalSource in November 2026: the scale holds eight in ten of them, and the shaded band the middle half.

$1,500Typical rent for 3-bedroom houses and townhouses in Indianapolis
$1,330–$1,750Middle half of their rents
39 daysAverage time they have been listed

See 3+ bedroom rentals in Indianapolis

Rent History

This home was last listed for rent on RentalSource from August to September 2023, ending at $975. Today's rent is $225 higher.

Rent history for this home, newest first
DateEventRentChange
November 13, 2026 Listed for rent $1,200+23.1% +23.1%
September 2, 2023 Listing removed $975
August 6, 2023 Listing removed $975
July 8, 2023 Listing removed $1,125
November 13, 2021 Listing removed $1,000

These are listed prices. What renters actually paid may have been different.

Affordability Calculator

Can I afford to live at 3540 Caroline Ave?
Bedrooms
3 bedrooms
30%
10% Recommended 50%
Move the slider to select the percentage of your monthly income you're comfortable spending on rent. Typically, it's advised to spend about 30% or less on housing.
Recommended income
$48,000 /year
With your chosen rent-to-income ratio, an annual income of $48,000 is recommended to comfortably afford this 3-bedroom rental priced at $1,200 per month.
For more information on rent affordability, visit our rent calculator or rent vs. buy calculator.

Commute

How long would the trip to work or school be from here? Add where you go, and see the drive, bike ride or walk from this home and from every home you look at.

House for rent
$1,200
Can I afford this home?
Interested in 3540 Caroline Ave?
Find out more about this property & see if it's available now.
Property managed by
Tiffany
(463) 295-0722
Avoid rental scams - Situations involving wire transfers or a landlord who can't meet you in person can be red flags.
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218
House for rent
$1,200
Can I afford this home?
Interested in 3540 Caroline Ave?
Find out more about this property & see if it's available now.
Property managed by
Tiffany
(463) 295-0722
Avoid rental scams - Situations involving wire transfers or a landlord who can't meet you in person can be red flags.
$1,200
House for rent
1 of 10
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 1
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 2
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 3
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 4
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 5
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 6
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 7
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 8
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 9
3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent - Image 10

Ask About 3540 Caroline Ave

3540 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 - House for Rent

Similar Houses in 46218

Discover Nearby Houses

What's New on the Blog

Explore recent posts on our blog, curated for renters, landlords, and industry pros.

List Your Property for Rent

Are You a Rental Professional?

Advertise on RentalSource, Zillow, Realtor.com, Zumper and more to attract quality tenants faster and take your listings to the next level.