Filters Save search

Houses for Rent in New Haven, IN

Showing 2 rentals in New Haven, then 18 more within 25 miles, nearest first.
1-20 of 20 rentals

More rentals near New Haven

Viewing 1-20 of 20 rentals in and near New Haven
What to Know About

Life in New Haven & Beyond

New Haven shares many of the great qualities that make Indiana a desirable place to live.

Indiana is where the past meets the present, and the great outdoors is right at your fingertips. Get to know the rich cultural heritage of this Midwestern gem by visiting incredible museums like the Eiteljorg Museum of American Indians and Western Art, or check out the top universities like Purdue University and Indiana University. Indiana is a hub of economic activity, with its thriving manufacturing, agriculture, and transportation industries.

The state also offers plenty of opportunities for those seeking adventure and excitement. From exploring the beautiful state parks to fishing in its many lakes and rivers, Indiana is a nature-lovers paradise from the Hoosier National Forest to the Ohio River. And for sports fans, check out the Indianapolis Colts (NFL) and Indiana Pacers (NBA) or catch a game at universities like Purdue or Indiana. In addition, discover famous attractions like the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, home of the world-famous Indianapolis 500 race, the Children's Museum of Indianapolis, and the historic town of Brown County.

With its strong economy, quality education, and lively atmosphere, Indiana is the perfect place to live.

Rental Market Trends

New Haven, IN

As of November 2026, New Haven's rental market is highly competitive, with rentals spending about 17 days on the market, faster than in Indiana (27), and rents up 6.0% over the past year. New Haven's average rent is 3.7% ($53) lower than the Indiana average of $1,452 and 31.3% ($637) lower than the U.S. average of $2,036.

Average Rent
$1,399
Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change
Increased0.51% ($7)
Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
Increased6.0% ($80)
Days on Market
17
Unit Type Average Rent Monthly ChangeMonth Over Month Change Yearly ChangeYear Over Year Change
1 Bed $985 Increased0.46% ($5) Increased5.6% ($52)
2 Beds $1,177 Increased0.04% Increased0.4% ($5)
3 Beds $1,549 Increased0.68% ($10) Increased5.6% ($83)
Nearby Cities Average Rent Avg. Rent vs. New HavenAverage Rent vs. New Haven Days on Market
Woodburn $1,265 Decreased9.6% ($134) 17 days
Grabill $1,349 Decreased3.6% ($50) 17 days
Fort Wayne $1,182 Decreased15.5% ($217) 21 days
Spencerville $1,420 Increased1.5% ($21) 17 days
Huntertown $1,552 Increased10.9% ($153) 17 days
Based on rentals advertised on RentalSource in and around New Haven.
Frequently Asked Questions
New Haven Rental Market FAQs

Explore rental prices, market conditions, and affordability in New Haven, IN.

The average rent in New Haven, IN is about $1,399 per month.
In New Haven, the average rent is about $985 per month for a 1-bedroom house, about $1,177 for a 2-bedroom house and about $1,549 for a 3-bedroom house.
The average rent in New Haven is 31.3% ($637) lower than the national average of $2,036 per month.
The rental market in New Haven, IN is currently highly competitive, with rentals spending about 17 days on the market, faster than in Indiana (27), and rents up 6.0% over the past year.
Based on the current averages, a household would need an annual income of about $47,100 to comfortably afford a 2-bedroom house in New Haven.
What's New on the Blog

Explore recent posts on our blog, curated for renters, landlords, and industry pros.

List Your Property for Rent

Are You a Rental Professional?

Advertise on RentalSource, Zillow, Realtor.com, Zumper and more to attract quality tenants faster and take your listings to the next level.