Property Managers in New Castle, IN

The companies with homes for rent in New Castle, and what each one has available.

Updated November 22, 2026

4
Property managers
11
Rentals available
$736
Average rent
69%
Of New Castle rentals

4 Property Managers in New Castle

Sorted by rentals available. Each photo is a home that company has for rent now.

RentalSource does not own or manage these properties and does not endorse any company listed. Companies appear here because they advertise rentals in New Castle.

New Castle Property Managers

How the companies compare, and how this list works.

4 property management companies and leasing teams are advertising 11 rentals in New Castle on RentalSource right now. Together they account for 69% of the 16 rentals we list in New Castle.
By rentals currently available: Slingshot Property & Asset Management (5), Wilmoth Group (3), Golden Sky Management (2). Counts change daily as homes are leased and new ones are listed.
Homes from the companies on this page rent from $600 – $1,100 a month, with an average of $736. Each company's card shows its own rent range in New Castle.
Open a company to see every rental it has available, then use Check availability on the home you like. Your message goes directly to the people leasing it, and RentalSource never charges renters a fee.
It is built from the rentals advertised on RentalSource and refreshed every day. Companies are added automatically once they have enough rentals available. Featured companies are labeled, and are shown first where they have several rentals. RentalSource does not own or manage these properties and does not endorse any company listed.
Companies are added automatically when they advertise rentals in New Castle on RentalSource. To be featured, list your rentals on a paid plan: property managers and agents on one get a Featured badge and priority placement where they have rentals.

What's New on the Blog

Recent posts for landlords and property managers.

More landlord resources

Do You Manage Rentals in New Castle?

Property managers and agents on a paid plan are featured in this directory, with a Featured badge and priority placement where they have rentals.